Backpacks or Totes? How to Choose the Best Bag for College in 2025

Every student needs a bag they can rely on. Some prefer the comfort and organization of a backpack, while others enjoy the simplicity and style of a tote. Both can work for college — it depends on how much you carry, how far you walk, and what fits your routine.

This guide compares backpacks and totes, highlights the strengths of each, and shares some standout options for 2025 — including eco-friendly picks for students who care about sustainability as much as style.

Backpacks vs. Totes: Key Differences

Backpacks

• Two straps for balanced weight
• Best for heavier loads, laptops, and all-day wear
• Multiple compartments and padded laptop sleeves
• Ergonomic support for long days
• Sporty, practical, and built for function

Totes

• One shoulder strap, easy to grab and go
• Best for lighter loads and short commutes
• Open design with fewer compartments
• Minimalist and fashion-forward style
• Versatile everyday carry

Best Backpacks for College in 2025

MADE FREE® Urban Pack (Charcoal)  — Best Eco-Friendly Backpack

Handcrafted from organic cotton canvas and biodegradable leather, this backpack blends everyday practicality with purpose. Padded straps, a laptop sleeve, and roomy compartments make it ideal for campus life. Each purchase also funds a day of freedom for someone escaping poverty or trafficking.

Why we chose it: This backpack combines sustainability with functionality. Made from organic cotton canvas and biodegradable leather, it reflects MADE FREE®’s mission of ethical fashion and fair-trade jobs. We chose it because it proves eco-friendly can also mean durable and practical.

Patagonia Refugio Daypack 26L  — Best All-Around Backpack

A versatile classic made from recycled materials with a removable laptop sleeve and breathable back panel. Comfortable, durable, and ready for long days of classes.

Why we chose it: Patagonia is known for long-lasting gear and environmental leadership. The Refugio is a classic for students because it balances comfort, storage, and a slim profile.

The North Face Recon — Most Comfortable Backpack

Designed with ergonomic straps and FlexVent™ suspension, the Recon is a student favorite for carrying heavier loads comfortably across campus.

Why we chose it: Comfort matters when you’re hauling books all day. The Recon is a campus staple because of its ergonomic design.

Best Totes for College in 2025

MADE FREE® Day Tote (Sand) — Best Sustainable Tote

Durable, spacious, and timeless. Made from organic cotton canvas, this tote fits a laptop and daily essentials. Like all MADE FREE® products, each one supports dignified work for artisans.

Why we chose it: Students told us they wanted a tote that wasn’t just stylish but durable enough for everyday use. MADE FREE®’s Day Tote checks both boxes, with sustainable materials and enough space for a laptop.

Baggu Duck Bag — Best Budget-Friendly Tote

A simple, recycled cotton canvas tote that’s lightweight yet big enough for notebooks and a laptop. Great for lighter days.

Why we chose it: Affordability and simplicity make the Duck Bag a great option for students who don’t need all the extras.

Everlane ReNew Weekender — Best Commuter Tote

Why we chose it: Not all students live on campus — some commute, and they need a tote that’s secure and structured. The ReNew Transit Tote is designed for exactly that.

Which One Should You Choose?

• Choose a backpack if you:
  • Carry a laptop every day
  • Walk long distances on campus
  • Want compartments to stay organized
• Choose a tote if you:
  • Travel light
  • Prefer quick access to your things
  • Want a sleek bag that transitions from class to coffee shops

FAQs

Can a tote really work for college?

Yes, especially for lighter days. If you carry heavy textbooks or a laptop regularly, a backpack is usually more comfortable.

Are eco-friendly bags as durable as regular ones?

They can be — brands like MADE FREE® and Patagonia build products with longevity in mind, and some even offer long warranties.

Which is better for sustainability?

Both can be eco-friendly if made from organic or recycled materials. What matters most is choosing brands that prioritize ethical production.

Conclusion

Both backpacks and totes can be great for college — it comes down to your daily routine and personal style. Backpacks shine in comfort and organization, while totes offer versatility and simplicity.

For students who want a bag that lasts and makes an impact, MADE FREE® offers both: the Urban Pack for backpack lovers and the Day Tote for tote fans. Each one is built to carry your essentials — and carry forward a mission of freedom and sustainability.